Trial Success: Favorable Settlement in High-Stakes Commercial Real Estate and Construction Dispute

After four weeks of intensive trial in a highly complex commercial real estate and construction matter, MSW Partners Anthony Capasso and Brant Forrest secured an exceptional settlement on behalf of our client.

This underscores MSW’s unwavering commitment to delivering outstanding results in the most demanding and high-stakes disputes. We commend Anthony and Brant for their extraordinary dedication, skillful trial execution, and the relentless pursuit of our client’s interests throughout every phase of this complex proceeding.

MSW Partners Chris Murphy and Kellen Murphy on The Anti-Architect Podcast with Christian Giordano

Murphy Schiller & Wilkes LLP is pleased to share that Chris Murphy and Kellen Murphy were recently featured on the Anti-Architect Podcast, hosted by Christian Giordano.

The Anti-Architect Podcast brings together business leaders and professionals for candid conversations about their experiences, perspectives and the ideas shaping their industries.

In this episode, Chris and Kellen sit down with Christian for an engaging conversation, sharing insights from their experiences and discussing their approach to business, leadership and the work they do at MSW.

Listen to the full episode:

Spotify: https://open.spotify.com/episode/7uzv3yGwAK7n7uzKONDok2

Apple Podcasts: https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/ep-93-kellen-murphy-and-chris-murphy-of-murphy/id1552247664?i=1000789948320

YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vfPW5fTnF6w

We invite you to tune in and hear the full conversation.

MSW Welcomes Alexandra Natale to Litigation and Construction Law Practice Groups

NEWARK, N.J. – Murphy Schiller & Wilkes LLP (“MSW”) is pleased to announce that Alexandra Natale has joined the firm as an Associate in its Litigation and Construction Law Practice Groups.

Alexandra joins MSW following a judicial clerkship with the Honorable Maria A. Giammona, J.S.C., in the Superior Court of New Jersey, where she gained extensive experience in legal research, motion practice, and judicial decision-making. During her clerkship, she drafted bench memoranda, orders, and opinions and assisted the court in addressing a wide range of complex legal and procedural issues.

Prior to her clerkship, Alexandra worked at a well-respected regional law firm, where she supported attorneys in civil litigation, appellate matters, regulatory disputes, and other complex legal proceedings. She also served as a Judicial Intern in the United States Bankruptcy Court for the District of New Jersey, gaining additional experience in bankruptcy and restructuring matters.

“We are excited to welcome Alexandra to the firm,” said Anthony Capasso, Partner and Chair of MSW’s Litigation and Construction Law Practice Groups. “Her judicial experience, strong legal writing and analytical skills, and exposure to a broad range of litigation matters make her an excellent addition to our team. We look forward to the contributions she will make as we continue to serve our clients throughout New Jersey and beyond.”

Alexandra earned her Juris Doctor from Suffolk University Law School and her Bachelor of Arts in English from the University of Virginia, where she was a member of the University’s Division I rowing team.

MSW Welcomes Joseph A. Natale as Partner in Litigation and Construction Law Practice Groups

NEWARK, N.J. – Murphy Schiller & Wilkes LLP (MSW) is pleased to announce that Joseph A. Natale has joined the firm as a Partner in its Litigation and Construction Law Practice Groups.

Mr. Natale’s practice focuses on resolving disputes arising from the ownership, development, leasing, construction, and operation of commercial real estate. He represents developers, property owners, investors, contractors, and construction professionals in matters involving partnership and joint venture disputes, commercial lease disputes, land and property-related claims, construction contract disputes, and other complex real estate and construction litigation.

“Joe’s arrival reflects our continued investment in growing our litigation and construction capabilities,” said Chris Murphy, Co-Founding Partner of MSW. “His experience handling sophisticated commercial real estate and construction disputes, coupled with his leadership within the New Jersey legal community, makes him an outstanding addition to our firm. We are excited to welcome him to MSW.”

Mr. Natale handles all phases of litigation in state and federal courts, including pre-trial proceedings, trials, chancery matters, appeals, private arbitrations, and administrative proceedings. In addition to representing clients in litigation and dispute resolution matters, he advises clients on risk management and assists in the preparation and negotiation of construction-related agreements.

“I am excited to join MSW and contribute to the firm’s continued growth,” said Mr. Natale. “MSW has developed an exceptional reputation for providing sophisticated counsel and practical solutions to developers, property owners, and business clients. I look forward to working with my new colleagues and serving our clients’ legal needs.”

An active leader within New Jersey’s legal community, Mr. Natale currently serves as Treasurer of the Young Lawyers Division of the New Jersey State Bar Association and is Co-Chair of its Membership Committee. He is also a member of the NJSBA’s Membership Committee, Equity Jurisprudence Special Committee, and Business and Commercial Litigation Special Committee. In addition, he serves as a Trustee of the Morris County Bar Foundation and as Co-Chair of the Morris County Bar Association’s Construction Law Committee.

Mr. Natale has been recognized for his professional accomplishments by numerous organizations. He was named the Morris County Bar Association’s Outstanding Young Lawyer of the Year in 2024 and received NJBIZ’s Leaders in Law Rising Star Award and the New Jersey Law Journal’s New Leaders of the Bar recognition in 2025. He has also been recognized in Best Lawyers: Ones to Watch for Commercial Litigation and Professional Malpractice Law and in Super Lawyers New Jersey Rising Stars for Business Litigation.

Mr. Natale earned his J.D. from Seton Hall University School of Law and his B.A. in Political Science from Tufts University. Prior to entering private practice, he served as Judicial Law Clerk to the Honorable Owen C. McCarthy, J.S.C., in the Superior Court of New Jersey, Monmouth Vicinage, Law Division, Civil Part. He is admitted to practice in New Jersey and New York.

Newark’s Affordable Housing Crisis Won’t Be Solved by Making Development Impossible

By Chris Murphy, Partner, Murphy Schiller & Wilkes LLP

Newark stands at a crossroads. For years, the city has worked to attract private investment in new housing, an effort that, despite persistent headwinds, has shown real progress. Mixed-income developments have risen in neighborhoods that spent decades waiting for reinvestment. Affordable units have been built alongside market-rate apartments, creating the kind of integrated, economically diverse communities that good housing policy is supposed to produce. None of it came easily, and none of it was inevitable.

Now, two simultaneous policy shifts threaten to undo all of it.

On July 23, 2026, the New Jersey Economic Development Authority (NJEDA) paused the Aspire Tax Credit Program, the state’s primary incentive for catalyzing mixed-use and residential development in cities like Newark. Weeks later, on August 5, 2026, the Newark Municipal Council voted 7–2 to refer a proposed amendment to the city’s Inclusionary Zoning Ordinance to the Central Planning Board for review. This week, the Central Planning Board voted to refer the proposed amendment back to the City Council with a recommendation that it be adopted. Taken together, these actions could freeze new residential development in Newark at precisely the moment the city needs it most.

Let me be clear: I support affordable housing. I have spent my entire career in New Jersey real estate law, and I understand the urgent need for housing that working families can actually afford. But good intentions do not build buildings. Capital does. And capital is rational. It flows to places where projects can be underwritten, financed, and built. When the math doesn’t work, the capital goes elsewhere, or it simply stays on the sidelines. That is not ideology. It is arithmetic.

The Aspire Program Made the Math Work.

Newark’s existing Inclusionary Zoning Ordinance, adopted in 2017 and amended several times since, requires that any new residential or mixed-use development of 15 or more units set aside 20% of its total units as income-restricted affordable housing. That is a meaningful obligation. For a 200-unit multifamily project, it means 40 units must be rented at below-market rates to households earning no more than 40%, 60%, or 80% of the Area Median Income.

The Aspire Tax Credit Program (and its predecessor program) helped bridge the gap between what developers could charge for those restricted units and what it actually costs to build them. The tax credits, awarded over a multi-year period, provided the financial cushion that made inclusionary projects pencil. Without Aspire, many of the projects currently in Newark’s pipeline would never have broken ground.

Aspire is on pause. The NJEDA has indicated it expects to begin accepting applications again in the fall, but no specific timeline has been set. Anyone who has worked with government programs knows that “fall” can easily become winter, and winter can become next year. In the meantime, developers who were counting on those credits to close financing gaps are scrambling. Projects in predevelopment are being shelved. Lenders are pulling back. The pipeline is drying up.

The Proposed Amendment Makes a Hard Problem Harder.

Into this vacuum, the City of Newark has proposed an amendment to its Inclusionary Zoning Ordinance that would fundamentally redefine how affordable housing obligations are calculated. The amendment does two things that should alarm anyone who actually wants to see affordable housing built in Newark.

First, it redefines “Median Income” from the regional median, the standard used across New Jersey’s affordable housing framework, to the Newark-specific median income, which the amendment pegs at just 42% of the regional figure, or approximately $58,490. This is not a technical adjustment. It is a seismic shift. Every income threshold in the ordinance is anchored to the median income definition. By resetting the benchmark to a figure that is less than half of the current standard, the amendment would require developers to price affordable units at income levels so low that the rents cannot come close to covering operating costs, let alone debt service.

Consider the numbers. Under the current ordinance, the largest tier of affordable units in a 200-unit project, 20 units at 80% of the regional AMI, can be rented to households earning roughly $111,000 per year, translating to rents of approximately $2,785 per month. Under the proposed amendment’s baseline option, those same 20 units would be restricted to households earning no more than 34% of the Newark Median Income, approximately $19,900 per year. The maximum permissible rent would be roughly $497 per month. That is an 82% reduction in the income a developer can underwrite against for a significant portion of the required affordable units.

No tax credit, density bonus, or parking waiver on earth can bridge a gap that wide.

Second, the amendment introduces a tiered structure offering developers the option of a higher set-aside, up to 31% or more of total units, in exchange for access to a “workforce housing” tier at 100% to 120% of the Newark Median Income. On its face, this looks like flexibility. In practice, it is a Hobson’s choice. Option 1, the baseline 20% set-aside, imposes income restrictions so severe that the units are essentially unfundable without deep subsidy. Options 2 and 3 require developers to designate 25% to 35% of their total units as affordable, far more than the current 20%, and even the most favorable income tier in those options (120% of Newark Median Income, or about $70,200) remains well below what was the 80%-of-AMI threshold under the existing ordinance.

The Consequences Are Predictable.

If both of these policy shifts take effect simultaneously, the Aspire pause and the amended IZO, the consequences are not just foreseeable, they are inevitable. Developers will not build projects they cannot finance. Lenders will not underwrite loans against rental income streams that cannot service debt. Equity investors will redirect capital to municipalities with clearer, more predictable regulatory frameworks. The result will not be more affordable housing in Newark. It will be less housing of every kind, affordable and market-rate alike.

This is not speculation. We are already seeing it. Higher interest rates driven by elevated bond yields have compressed returns across the industry. Construction costs remain stubbornly high. Insurance premiums have surged. In this environment, every additional dollar of regulatory cost or uncertainty tips the balance sheet from feasible to infeasible. Newark is competing for a finite pool of development capital against cities and suburbs across the region and the country. Making Newark’s regulatory environment more burdensome, at the very moment the state has pulled the rug out from under developers, sends exactly the wrong signal to the market. Capital has options. Newark needs to give it a reason to stay.

A Better Path Forward.

Newark deserves an affordable housing policy that actually produces affordable housing. That means crafting requirements that developers can realistically meet, not aspirational mandates that look impressive in a press release but produce zero units on the ground.

Earlier this week, the Central Planning Board voted to refer the proposed amendment back to the City Council with a recommendation that it be adopted. The Municipal Council will now vote on final adoption. Before it does, I urge the Council to consider the following:

  • Do not decouple from the regional income standard. Newark’s affordable housing obligations should remain tied to the regional median income, consistent with the framework used across New Jersey. Adopting a city-specific median that is 42% of the regional figure will make Newark an outlier in ways that discourage investment without producing commensurate housing benefits.
  • Coordinate with Trenton on Aspire. Before layering new affordability mandates on developers, the City should engage the NJEDA to understand the timeline for Aspire’s return. If the program remains unavailable or uncertain, the City must calibrate its own requirements accordingly.
  • Model the financial impact. The City Council should commission an independent feasibility analysis of the proposed amendment’s impact on a representative set of development prototypes. If the numbers show that projects cannot be built under the new framework, the amendment should be revised before adoption, not after the damage is done.
  • Preserve the existing framework while improving it. The current 20% set-aside at regional AMI thresholds, combined with the density bonus, parking reductions, and fee waivers already in the ordinance, represents a workable, if imperfect, framework. Incremental improvements to that structure will produce more affordable units than a wholesale rewrite that stops development altogether.

The goal of housing policy should be to produce housing. If this amendment passes, Newark will have chosen symbolism over substance, and the families who need affordable housing will pay the price.

The full article from BINJE can be found here: Newark’s Affordable Housing Initiatives Explained – BINJE | New Jersey Business News

Chris J. Murphy is a founding partner of Murphy Schiller and Wilkes LLP (MSW) and a member of the firm’s Executive Committee. He chairs both the Tax Credits and Incentives Practice and the Land Use, Zoning and Redevelopment Practice, overseeing two of the firm’s core statewide platforms. In these roles, he has helped clients secure approvals for more than one billion dollars in tax credits and incentives administered by the New Jersey Economic Development Authority and thousands of multifamily residential units throughout New Jersey.

MSW Secures Approval for 5.5-Acre ISO Project in South Plainfield

The Murphy Schiller & Wilkes LLP (MSW) Land Use Team is excited to announce that it has secured amended preliminary and final site plan approval including a use variance for industrial outdoor storage in South Plainfield.

The approved project is situated on a 5.5 acre lot and includes a modern 20,000 SF industrial building with office space and interior storage/maintenance areas, industrial outdoor storage space, and significant landscaping improvements.

The project was successfully presented by MSW Partner Thomas Garlick, Civil Engineer Tom Trotto of Dynamic Engineering, Traffic Engineer Corey Chase from Dynamic Traffic, Architects Michael Soriano and Bob Longo of Cornerstone Architecture Group, and Professional Planner John Taikina. MSW Paralegal Stephanie McLeish also provided assistance to the development team.

The application received unanimous approval from the South Plainfield Zoning Board of Adjustment.

MSW congratulates our client and the entire development team on another successful project in Middlesex County.

MSW Secures Approval for Mixed-Use Redevelopment Project in North Arlington

Murphy Schiller & Wilkes, LLP is proud to announce that we have secured site plan approval for a significant redevelopment project in North Arlington.

The project will transform an existing Veterans of Foreign Wars (VFW) property into a new three-story mixed-use building featuring a modern VFW facility on the ground floor, along with 40 age-restricted residential units on the upper floors, including affordable housing.

MSW was proud to handle all aspects of the redevelopment effort and represent our client throughout the Planning Board approval process. Congratulations to Matt Gilson, Esq., who served as lead attorney on the redevelopment application, and Michael Silbert, Esq., who successfully handled the Planning Board hearing, with the assistance of Stephanie McLeish. Their dedication and expertise, together with the efforts of the entire project team, helped move this important project one step closer to fruition.

We also extend our thanks to Yosef Portnoy, P.E., and the team at Civil Core Consulting, whose civil engineering and site design work played an important role in securing the approval.

We are excited to see this project move forward and help deliver a new home for the VFW while creating much-needed senior housing opportunities for the North Arlington community.

Another great project. Another great result for our client.

MSW Welcomes Daniel Kraft as Counsel in Transactional Real Estate Practice

MSW Welcomes Daniel Kraft as Counsel in Transactional Real Estate Practice

NEWARK, N.J. – Murphy Schiller & Wilkes LLP (MSW) is pleased to announce that Daniel Kraft has joined the firm as Counsel in its Transactional Real Estate Practice.

Daniel brings more than twenty-five years of experience representing lenders, borrowers, investors, developers, property owners, and businesses in sophisticated commercial real estate matters. His practice is concentrated in real estate finance, including acquisition, construction, and refinancing transactions, as well as commercial real estate acquisitions and dispositions, leasing, and development projects.

Throughout his career, Daniel has structured, negotiated, documented, and closed a broad range of commercial real estate transactions. He has extensive experience drafting and negotiating loan documentation, purchase and sale agreements, and commercial leases, while guiding clients through due diligence and advising on title, zoning, land use, survey, environmental, and other matters critical to successful transactions.

Prior to joining MSW, Daniel served as general counsel to real estate investment and development organizations, where he advised on financings, acquisitions, dispositions, leasing, development, construction, and operational matters. Earlier in his career, he served as underwriting counsel with a national title insurance company, handling complex title issues and high-value commercial real estate transactions across the United States.

“Daniel’s deep experience in commercial real estate finance and his broad transactional background make him an outstanding addition to our firm,” said Kellen F. Murphy, Managing Partner at MSW. “His practical approach, technical skill, and understanding of the business objectives that drive real estate transactions will be a tremendous asset to our clients.”

“I am excited to join MSW and work alongside such a talented team,” said Daniel Kraft. The firm’s commitment to client service and its growing transactional practice make it an ideal fit, and I look forward to helping clients navigate complex real estate transactions and achieve their business objectives.”

Daniel earned his J.D. from Rutgers Law School and his B.A. from Cornell University. He is admitted to practice law in New Jersey.

MSW Attorneys recognized as 2027 Best Lawyers / Ones to Watch in America

Murphy Schiller & Wilkes LLP (MSW) is proud to announce that six of its attorneys have been recognized in the 2027 editions of The Best Lawyers in America®️ and Best Lawyers: Ones to Watch®️ in America.

Susan C. Karp, Matthew J. Schiller and Charles J. Wilkes have once again been recognized by The Best Lawyers in America, while Matthew E. Gilson, Benjamin Lindeman and Paige Guarino have been named among Best Lawyers: Ones to Watch in America.

  • Susan C. Karp, Counsel – Recognized for her work in Environmental Law, advising clients on environmental compliance, regulatory matters, land development and remediation.
  • Matthew J. Schiller, Partner – Recognized for his work in Real Estate Law, representing clients in complex transactions, financings and development projects.
  • Charles J. Wilkes, Partner – Recognized for his work in Real Estate Law, with a focus on sophisticated real estate, land use and redevelopment matters.
  • Matthew E. Gilson, Partner – Named to Best Lawyers: Ones to Watch in America for his professional excellence and contributions to the legal profession.
  • Benjamin Lindeman – Named to Best Lawyers: Ones to Watch in America in recognition of his professional achievement and growing contributions to the firm and its clients.
  • Paige Guarino – Named to Best Lawyers: Ones to Watch in America in recognition of her professional excellence and commitment to client service.

First published in 1983, The Best Lawyers in America is one of the legal profession’s most respected peer-review publications. Its recognitions are based on evaluations by attorneys of their peers. Best Lawyers: Ones to Watch in America uses the same peer-review methodology to recognize outstanding attorneys earlier in their careers.

“We are proud to see Susan, Matt, Charles, Matthew, Benjamin and Paige recognized by their peers,” said the partners of Murphy Schiller & Wilkes LLP. “These honors reflect the talent, dedication and commitment to client service that define MSW.”

MSW congratulates all six attorneys on this well-deserved recognition and thanks the firm’s clients and colleagues for their continued trust.
For more information, visit BestLawyers.com.